I transformed the lyrics of Georg Kreisler’s song Entweder oder (Either, or) into English.
First I had to find a word that matched the recurring monosyllabic German shortened word for »something«, »was«, because »something« was too long for the meter. But was there an English word for that little »etwas« (»something«) that is just »was« (»some?« »thing?«)? And how could I represent the »wos« intonation of Kreisler’s dialect, that is beaming it into a similar let’s say nonchalant linguistic sphere?
As you can see down there, »shit« came in handy, the shit of »Bla bla bla and shit«-sentences. Predictably, one line in this English version now goes »...or I shit shit«.
It’s not the funniest one. There is no single funniest line. The verses reinforce one another, and they become this great song.
I changed the meaning of one verse though. In »...or I nosh shit«, I replaced »shit« with a pronoun to avoid repeating the song’s brilliant first line, »Either I eat shit« (for which I made a literal translation of »fressen« as »gulp« to allow readers to come up themselves with the obvious »eat shit« phrase fun in their brains.) But there is no audible difference between »nosh shit« and »nosh it« unless the singer makes an effort at over-pronouncing – »noSH SHit« – like when they sing a Schubert lied.
So when listened to, the complete translation is somewhat literal. Semantically, this one line does change Kreisler’s meaning. But I have no scruples about it because Kreisler’s original line is itself ambivalent. With »...vernasch was«, he could be seducing Candy or nibble at candy, or wasting too much money on both.
I’ll update this post with notes on some problems with intransitive verbs.
Now listen to »Entweder oder«
...that is: Georg Kreisler: Either, or
Either I gulp shit,
or I drink shit
or I have shit
or I buy shit
or I bear shit
or I smoke shit
or I steal shit
or I need shit
Or I seek shit
or I find shit
or I take shit
or I rack shit
or I hear shit
or I see shit
or I shit shit
or I reek shit
Or I read shit
or I write shit
or I quaff shit
or I puke shit
or I paste shit
or I build shit
or I play shit
or I slap shit
Or I sleep shit
or I dream shit
or I laugh shit
or fail shit
or I pay shit
or cash shit
or I get shit
or lose shit
Or I vote shit
or I drive shit
or I hope shit
or I was shit
or I smear shit
or I wash shit
or I learn shit
or nosh it